The Clean Power Plan has been replaced by the Trump power plan … which is literally no plan at all

euronews (in English) / YouTube Spain 39 s unprofitable coal industry 1560980911.jpg...
euronews (in English) / YouTube

The Trump EPA, now under the guidance of coal lobbyist Andrew Wheeler, has completed its review and replacement of the rules for coal-fired power plants that were put into effect by President Barack Obama. And that replacement is … do whatever you want.

The new rules are that there are no rules. Instead, the federal government will turn over the regulation of plants to the states, allowing each to set its own targets. States will be allowed to decide how much restriction they want to put on coal emissions, including no restrictions at all. In all likelihood, states will choose to ride out the current requirements, just keeping things on cruise as coal plants cycle out of existence.

This change could potentially allow coal plants to stay open longer. Many of the existing plants are over 40 years old, and well past the date when they were due for replacement or major upgrades. Republicans blamed the increased costs implied by forcing these plants to meet the obligations under the Clean Power Plan for the rapid phase-out of coal power. However, the decline of coal hasn’t paused since Trump took office. In fact, the percentage of electrical power produced from coal in the United States is currently at the lowest level ever recorded and still falling. Almost half of what remains is scheduled for closure in the next decade. And that’s despite industry expectations that this change to the rules was coming.

The reason is simple enough: Coal has been priced out of the market. It’s not just that cheap natural gas and rapidly falling prices for wind and solar have challenged coal on a dollar per BTU basis; coal plants are also much more expensive to build and more expensive to maintain. Efficient coal plants are also huge, making it difficult to bring on additional capacity incrementally, a problem not faced by either natural gas or renewables. There are many reasons why not a single new coal plant is in the works.

All of these factors mean that the change announced on Wednesday is more about Trump declaring victory in a nonexistent war on coal and thumbing his nose at the climate crisis than it is about making a real change to America’s energy production. Which isn’t to say that the non-plan isn’t an issue. Power providers already figured this change into their planning over the last two years, slowing the retirement of coal plants as they knew they would never face the Clean Power emission rules. But the biggest effect has probably been overseas, where Trump’s gifts to the industry have been frequently mentioned as evidence that there’s no need to step back from coal.

The Clean Power Plan was already hanging in limbo after court challenges led to its suspension in 2017. Both Wheeler and former Trump EPA administrator Scott Pruitt were involved in those challenges, and the White House refused to defend the plan.

The emissions requirements in the plan were never enforced, and never likely to be enforced. On a practical level, what’s killing coal is simply the availability of other energy sources that can be used to generate energy at a lower cost. Even when coal matches natural gas in BTU for BTU value, it has shipping, storage, maintenance, and clean-up costs that other fuels don’t share. The nation’s first “clean coal” plant actually switched to burning natural gas before it went into production. And by some measures, building new solar and wind capacity is actually cheaper than just maintaining a coal plant.

That’s the kind of statistic that shows nothing Trump is going to do is really going to affect the course of the U.S. energy market. Given the strength of the market forces involved, it’s unlikely there is any restriction Trump could remove that would significantly slow the death of coal. Which is why he and Energy Secretary Rick Perry have been considering using another national emergency to force power providers to keep burning coal under the pretext of energy security.

Short of taking that step, it’s unlikely Trump’s actions, or the new “anything goes” plan, will prevent coal from staggering toward its endgame—though it will allow mine owners to pocket a few more millions on their way off the national stage. Primarily this announcement is about messaging. It’s another in the list of Trump “achievements,” like those he listed at his Orlando rally; another thing that Trump can shout about while declaring he already Made America Great.

Unfortunately, it’s also something that providers in India, China, and across Asia can point to when they genuinely are building new coal plants. Why impose restrictions if the United States isn’t going to?

Trump’s new rule is unlikely to generate any more power in the U.S., but it’s certain to generate a new wave of lawsuits, this time from states and environmental groups opposing the new free-for-all. But it’s not environmental groups that are currently crushing Trump’s coal dreams. It’s simply dollars.

Thank you to all who already support our work since we could not exist without your generosity. If you have not already, please consider supporting us on Patreon to ensure we can continue bringing you the best of independent journalism.

Leave a Comment

1 Comment on "The Clean Power Plan has been replaced by the Trump power plan … which is literally no plan at all"

newest oldest most voted
True Patriot
True Patriot

Our air will look like China’s, and our economy will look like Russia’s.