The Trump administration is considering “novel” approaches to stop mass-shootings. Of course, the administration is not considering restricting the sale of military armaments to the nation’s average HVAC installer or PE teacher. No, the latest ideas focus upon monitoring the “mentally ill,” perhaps from their phones. Via the Washington Post:

Advisers to Wright quickly pulled together a three-page proposal — called SAFEHOME for Stopping Aberrant Fatal Events by Helping Overcome Mental Extremes – which calls for exploring whether technology like phones and smart watches can be used to detect when mentally ill people are about to turn violent.

Under no circumstances will you ever hear me make light of the ravages of mental illness, or pass up an opportunity to highlight the need for better, more compassionate healthcare for such insidious diseases. And we do certainly need to discuss mental health issues with regard to the mass-shooting epidemic.

However, fighting mental illness as the primary approach to decreasing mass-shootings is, well, insane. As you might guess, it is exceedingly difficult to effectively predict which people needing care are the type that will soon turn to violence.

“I would love if some new technology suddenly came along that would help us identify violent risk, but there’s so many things about this idea of predicting violence that doesn’t make sense,” said Marisa Randazzo, former chief research psychologist for the U.S. Secret Service.


Nor does it make any sense to take a gun designed to mow down fifty enemy fighters on a battlefield and sell that gun to the average produce section manager in Tulsa.

There are a few other pragmatic concerns about monitoring the phones of select at-risk people:

Beyond the civil liberty concerns about monitoring people through their gadgets, Randazzo said, there’s the problem of false positives.

Even if the technology could be developed, such a program would likely flag tens, or hundreds of thousands, more possible suspects than actual shooters. How, she asked, would you sort through them? And how would you know you were right, given the difficulty of proving something that hasn’t happened?

Yes, I can see how it might be a difficult correlation.

However, I have no difficulty correlating mass-shootings, especially those involving double digit victims, with the AR-15 and variants thereof. Indeed, we are getting to a point where it is a near 1:1 “correlation.” This nation once had the good sense to ban assault rifles like the AR-15.

Of course, addressing the AR-15 correlation is off the table, a non-starter. This country lacks the requisite mental health to gauge cause and effect, benefits versus costs, freedom to arm versus freedom to go out in public.

I would like to be able to take the Administration’s concern about mental illness and its role in mass shootings more seriously. But Republicans have been indefatigable in their effort to rid many Americans of access to healthcare generally (especially those with pre-existing conditions, such as mental illness). It is exceedingly difficult to imagine Republicans funding medical interventions that both help the sick and protect the innocent.

The current focus on mental illness” seems designed primarily to distract from the real question about deranged thought. Just what the fck are we doing selling military weaponry to the average Dorito-eating American?


Peace, y’all

Jason, and please follow me on Twitter @MiciakZoom



Liked it? Take a second to support Jason Miciak on Patreon!

This is a Creative Commons article. The original version of this article appeared here.


  1. No.. I totally disagree… Let the search of private cell phones by an AI, turn up 45 million false positives… because you now have to figure out some way to process those 45 million people, you will need to build some kind of bureaucracy to manage the process. I suggest taxing gun sales to pay for it… let them also manage gun safety, and violence prevention.

    Make sure nobody on that list can own any kind of gun. Donald will have removed guns from half the gun owners in the country. The NRA will have a stroke. Gun owners will declare war on the White House, and we end up with effective gun control by accident.

  2. I’ve taken care of mentally ill people & their thinking is so disorganized they can’t even manage meals & hygiene. They are not amassing weapons & bullets. They can barely manage grocery shopping & if there was concern why aren’t they pushing for expanded ACA & Medicaid to help these people? They’re homeless & helpless. Do you really think they’re buying expensive phones & watches to be monitored through? Ridiculous. The shooters are predominantly angry white men that aren’t getting the life of privilege they feel they deserve. Figure out how to get the guns away from them.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here