‘Not a Big Fan of Medicare for All’: Pelosi Attacks Plan Backed by Leading 2020 Democrats, Majority of Party

Washington Post / YouTube Pelosi holds weekly news conference 1557423122.jpg...
Washington Post / YouTube

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said in an interview Friday that she is “not a big fan of Medicare for All” despite support for the ambitious proposal among the majority of her caucus, three-quarters of Democratic voters, and two leading 2020 Democratic presidential candidates.

“It is expensive,” Pelosi told Bloomberg, without mentioning that studies show Medicare for All would save the U.S. trillions of dollars while providing comprehensive coverage to all.

“Who pays is very important,” continued Pelosi. “What are the benefits that come in there? So I would think that hopefully as we emerge into the election year, the mantra would be more ‘Healthcare for All Americans.'”

The Speaker added that “there is a comfort level that some people have with their current private insurance that they have, and if that is to be phased out, let’s talk about it.”

Progressive activist Jonathan Cohn denounced Pelosi’s comments as “sabotage” of two of the Democratic Party’s presidential frontrunners, Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.).


The comments were met with immediate outrage by Medicare for All proponents:

Pelosi’s remarks came just hours after Warren released a Medicare for All financing plan that she says would deliver a major tax cut for most families in the U.S. while also reducing national healthcare spending compared to the current for-profit system.

In a statement applauding Warren’s proposal, Social Security Works executive director Alex Lawson said “Medicare for All doesn’t cost money.”

“It saves money by eliminating the for-profit waste in the insurance system and ending the rip-off of paying the highest drug prices in the world,” said Lawson. “That’s why ‘how will you pay for it?’ has always been a completely false premise.”

Contrary to Pelosi’s suggestion that Medicare for All could damage Democrats’ chances in the 2020 election, recent polling (pdf) by Data for Progress showed “supporting Medicare for All would not hurt” the Democratic presidential nominee in a race against President Donald Trump.

“We tested a Democrat running on Medicare for All against Trump. Six times. With three different vendors,” Data for Progress co-founder Sean McElwee said Friday. “Every time the Medicare for All Democrat wins, usually by double-digits.”

Thank you to all who already support our work since we could not exist without your generosity. If you have not already, please consider supporting us on Patreon to ensure we can continue bringing you the best of independent journalism.

Leave a Comment

2 Comments on "‘Not a Big Fan of Medicare for All’: Pelosi Attacks Plan Backed by Leading 2020 Democrats, Majority of Party"

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
chris whitley
chris whitley

Well let’s talk about it. The republicans dislike it so it can’t be all bad.

True Patriot
True Patriot

Just expand the Affordable Care Act, for those who want to pay extreme prices, and go bankrupt after a serious medical event…let them. They evidently can afford it.