Legal observers and members of Congress react to Judge Ellis’ sentencing of Paul Manafort

Fox News / YouTube Political fallout from Paul Manafort ...
Fox News / YouTube

The reaction of legal observers and members of Congress to the extraordinarily lenient 47-month sentence, against the recommendations of federal prosecutors and delivered to former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort, one of the most corrupt human beings ever to be born of human skin, for his crimes… has been marked.

Democratic Rep. Eric Swalwell of California responded to the light sentence with irony, saying on “All In With Chris Hayes,” “I think I spent more days in detention in high school than Judge Ellis thinks that Paul Manafort should spend in jail for what he did to defraud the United States.”

As ably compiled by Dennis Romero of NBC News, some took note of the grotesque disparity in sentencing administered by the Reagan-appointed Judge Thomas Selby (”T.S.”) Ellis and those sentences involving people of a different social “class”.

Other observers highlighted the seeming incongruence between punishments for white-collar crime like Manafort’s and street crime, particularly administered against people of color.

The reactions also include those familiar with such crimes and the sentences they would expect to be laid down in such circumstances, as compared to considerably lesser offenses.

Brooklyn Defender Services in New York, which provides legal services to low-income people, Scott Hechinger posted a series of tweets, such as one saying, “My client yesterday was offered 36-72 months in prison for stealing $100 worth of quarters.”

Some commented on how the perversion of the Judiciary was made manifest by this particular Federal Judge.

“Judge Ellis has inexcusably perverted justice and the guidelines,” Harvard Law School professor and Trump critic Laurence Tribe tweeted.

One takeaway from Manafort’s sentence should be that that the administration of justice in this country is really dependent on Judges who do their job—and those who don’t.

“Even for this judge — who is known as an arbitrary and capricious sentenced and prone to downward departures in white collar case — this is a totally crazy and exorbitant departure,” tweeted former federal prosecutor Harry Litman.

Perhaps the most amazing historical remembrance from this fiasco will be Judge Ellis’ remarks during Manafort’s sentencing when he opined on the sentence that had been suggested by the prosecution.

Prior to announcing his decision, Judge T.S. Ellis called that range “excessive,” and said Manafort “has lived an otherwise blameless life.”

Elections have consequences. This is what can happen to our Justice system when biased Republicans—and (some) Judges appointed by them–are put in charge of it.
Thank you to all who already support our work since we could not exist without your generosity. If you have not already, please consider supporting us on Patreon to ensure we can continue bringing you the best of independent journalism.

Leave a Comment

5 Comments on "Legal observers and members of Congress react to Judge Ellis’ sentencing of Paul Manafort"

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Lone Wolf
Lone Wolf

Prior to announcing his decision, Judge T.S. Ellis called that range “excessive,” and said Manafort “has lived an otherwise blameless life.”

Um? except for murder, armed robbery, extortion, rum running, bootlegging and a long list of other crimes and misdeeds…Al Capone, Dutch Schultz, John Gotti, the uni freaking bomber, and Osama Bin Ladin all lived an otherwise blameless life too, until they didn’t!

another one bought and paid for? They better hope the check clears, remember WHO they are coming from, I’m just saying…


Either the judge is a tRump supporter or he was bought. Or both.


About time there’s a special investigation on the judicial sustem. Where’s the over sight there ?.
4yrs, less 9 months served ?
The nation is waiting with baited breath until next weeks court decision on manaforts fate or favour…
So, let me try and understand this..Rob a bank and steal $10 grand then get 10 – 20 yrs…
Systematically commit fraud, theft, evade, hide millions in federal taxes for decades then get a thank you appraisal from the sentancing judge, for a life without a record of being caught previously ?..

WTF !!

Cadet “Bone Spurs” said it best, ‘the system is rigged folks’..


Trump must have threatened Ellis & his family. Or Putin did it for him. Face it folks, we live under the control of a corrupt government-


This is why a criminal or an individual suspected of criminal behavior should not be allowed to appoint judges. “Money talks”, The rich get richer” these are old sayings but reflect the policies of the GOP and this administration to a tee. Trump took an oath but it is obvious he does not represent All the people of this Country.