FiveThirtyEight: does Trump have “Popularity Above Replacement”

Gage Skidmore / Flickr Donald Trump...
Gage Skidmore / Flickr

Battleground and swing states will save the GOP, its PACs, and the Russians much in the way of 2020 campaign costs, if FiveThirtyEight is correct about approval polling using Morning Consult data.

There’s some correlation between Trump’s popularity and partisanship with enough room for popularity slippage to make Trump still competitive in 2020.

52% of current voters who claim that they will not vote for Trump in 2020 won’t make any difference if they don’t show up to the polls and live in the wrong places. And then there’s the race/class/gender/age differentials that will make the conflicts much clearer.

Is it an auspicious sign for Trump that he isn’t more unpopular in New Mexico, Virginia, North Carolina, and Florida, given his unpopularity nationwide.”


Trump’s low approval ratings nationally aren’t as bad a sign for him as they might appear. If Trump is disproportionately unpopular in safely Republican states but his popularity roughly matches partisanship in swing states, his low national ratings shouldn’t have much of an impact on the Electoral College.…

At the present moment, Trump is in a worse position than a typical Republican president would be in Wisconsin, Texas, and Iowa. The problem is that much of the data is becoming inelastic.

In the spirit of my “Popularity Above Replacement” series, in which I’ve looked at how popular governors and senators were relative to the partisanship of their states, I wanted to see what Trump’s state-by-state approval ratings tell us beyond mere partisanship. To find out, I looked at the difference between Trump’s net approval rating (approval rating minus disapproval rating) in a given state according to Morning Consult’s latest polling and that state’s partisan lean (how much more Republican- or Democratic-leaning it is than the country as a whole).1 The result is Trump’s “Popularity Above Replacement President,” or PARP, score for each state.

There are six states where Trump’s net approval rating is higher than it “should” be based on partisan lean, from Rhode Island (+4) in the top spot to Alabama, where his PARP is barely positive (+0.2).

Rhode Island -22 D+26 +4
Mississippi +19 R+15 +4
Louisiana +20 R+17 +3
Hawaii -34 D+36 +2
Massachusetts -28 D+29 +1
Alabama +27 R+27 0

The state where Trump is most underperforming partisan lean is North Dakota — it is 33 points more Republican-leaning than the nation, but Trump’s approval rating there in April was only 6 points higher than his disapproval rating.

South Dakota +10 R+31 -21
New Hampshire -19 R+2 -21
Kansas +2 R+23 -21
Oklahoma +11 R+34 -23
Utah +5 R+31 -26
North Dakota +6 R+33 -27…

Thank you to all who already support our work since we could not exist without your generosity. If you have not already, please consider supporting us on Patreon to ensure we can continue bringing you the best of independent journalism.

Leave a Comment

2 Comments on "FiveThirtyEight: does Trump have “Popularity Above Replacement”"

newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Can anybody explain this in plain English. You know for those of us who are aren’t Wonks!

Lone Wolf
Lone Wolf

Too many of those Wonks who voted for the idiot in the first place will be too stubborn to admit the undeniable fact that Trump is just a lifelong loser at everything, and that somehow someway he will come through in the end as long as they all hang tough, and believe his lies, that he lies about to cover his lies, that have already been debunked, proven false, and have no factual basis at all, he just pulls shit out of his ass!