Cities across the U.S. are cutting and reallocating funds from police budgets as calls from an ongoing nationwide uprising over police violence for reimagining the country’s approach to law enforcement continue.
“Instead of protecting us, we’re terrified of the military-like forces that patrol and harass our neighborhoods. Yet we keep supporting a system that is clearly broken.”
—Mercedes Fulbright, Texas Working Families Party
“I hope that we don’t miss this moment,” Austin Mayor pro tem Delia Garza said after a meeting Thursday on reforming the city’s police department’s use of force and where the city council directed the city manager to cut the department’s budget. “Our community is at a boiling point.”
Austin is not alone in Texas—a few hundred miles away, the Dallas city government is also looking at cutting its police department’s budget as approval for an increase has stalled amid calls to defund.
Mercedes Fulbright, an organizing director for Texas Working Families Party, said in a statement that she and other members of the Dallas Movement for Black Lives coalition were happy the council heard their demands that the city not, at minimum, increase funding for the department.
“Policing doesn’t work. It never worked in the interest of our marginalized communities. Instead of protecting us, we’re terrified of the military-like forces that patrol and harass our neighborhoods," – Mercedes Fulbright, BYP100 Dallas. #DefundThePolice https://t.co/XYXESnixcn
— BYP100 (@byp100) June 12, 2020
“Policing doesn’t work,” said Fulbright. “It never worked in the interest of our marginalized communities. Instead of protecting us, we’re terrified of the military-like forces that patrol and harass our neighborhoods.”
“Yet we keep supporting a system that is clearly broken,” she said.
Fordham law professor John Pfaff pointed to the insufficient results from spending huge amounts on policing in city after city, noting that investing funds in drug treatment and healthcare rather than law enforcement have more positive effects than policing—raising the question of why cities around the country continue to pour money into departments.
“You don’t have to go full abolition to see that maybe sinking 1/3 of a city’s general budget into police is a problematic investment,” tweeted Pfaff.
City governments appear to be listening. Dallas and Austin are part of a growing number of municipalities around the country taking such action after demands from the protest movement sparked by the killing of George Floyd by four Minneapolis police officers last month.
The size of New York City police budgets, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) told Good Morning America‘s George Stephanopoulos on Wednesday, dwarfs social services spending in her city.
“The New York City Police department has a $6 billion dollar a year budget,” said Ocasio-Cortez. “That is more than we spend on youth, housing, healthcare, and homelessness combined.”
"The NYC Police dept. has a 6 Billion dollar a year budget. That is more than we spend on youth, housing, healthcare, and homelessness combined"
— CaseStudyQB (@CaseStudyQB) June 12, 2020
Activist Jonathan Cohn was skeptical of Walsh’s move.
Reallocating money from the police overtime budget just seems like sleight of hand.
You still owe overtime money when police do overtime. So you actually aren't cutting anything. #bospoli
— Jonathan "Boo and Vote" Cohn (@JonathanCohn) June 12, 2020
Hartford will redistribute the money to city departments for health and other public services, Mayor Luke Bronin told the Hartford Courant Thursday, and look to take police out of responding to situations where their presence can escalate things such as calls for mental health and drug abuse.
“Building a system for responding to those needs in real time, with trained, effective professionals outside of law enforcement won’t happen overnight, but it’s a goal that I embrace,” said Cronin. “That’s one part of the systemic change that I hope we can work on together, with non-profit partners and with the state, in the months ahead.”
The $1 million was less than the $9.6 million in cuts asked for by Working Families Party council members Wildaliz Bermudez and Joshua Michtom.
Portland commissioner Chloe Eudaly’s “no” vote helped send the budget back for further consideration.
According to Oregon Live:
Eudaly said the vote reminded her of regrets over voting yes to the city budget in 2018, which called for increased police funding. She said while she agreed with the changes to police spending her fellow commissioners made Thursday, she didn’t believe they went far enough and that members of the public “deserve better.”
“I can’t swallow another bitter budget pill in good conscience,” Eudaly said. “I vote no.”
San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju celebrated his city’s decision to ask for more cuts.
“The public call for transformative change is urgent,” said Raju. “The rejection of what amounts to an invisible budget cut is the very least we must do to answer this call.”
“A much smaller, much altered police department and policing model is what San Franciscans are calling for,” Raju added, “and the current moment demands nothing less.”
While many activists around the country like Raju find the level of cuts suggested thus far in the cities to be insufficient, the move to reallocate funding from departments at represents a shift in the way Americans are thinking about policing in the midst of the ongoing protest movement.
— Rachel Cohen (@rmc031) June 12, 2020
Despite the fact that two-thirds of Americans still oppose “defunding the police,” public support for the idea has spiked considerably in a number of recent polls. Part of that may be how the question is asked—HuffPost polling found a plurality, 44%, backing budgeting less money for the police and more for social services while only 27% supported defunding.
The fight needs to be about more than just police departments, Eric Levitz wrote at New York magazine Friday:
The activists and community organizers who’ve rallied behind “defund the police” are engaged in discrete struggles over fiscal priorities across a wide range of cities. As such, their focus on contesting police departments’ outsize share of municipal budgets is appropriate. But the fight must not end there. We cannot provide disadvantaged communities with the social resources they deserve—nor, in all likelihood, the social resources necessary for guaranteeing their safety in the absence of conventional policing—merely by reallocating existing public funds. Rather, doing so will require massively increasing overall public spending on these communities.
Seattle-based activist Nikkita Oliver told Vanity Fair Thursday that she hoped the movement would keep pushing city leaders around the country to do the right thing.
“Those structures were not made to be transformed from the inside out,” said Oliver. “They have to be transformed by the pressure that we’re creating.”